Anyone trying to remove the contents of a hot oven won’t last long with a folded up dishcloth. There is nothing that can beat the reliability, safety, and comfort of a quality pair. Even using one mitt can make a big difference although some are better than others.

A lot will depend on the material the oven mitt is made from as well as the reliability so, for your safety, it is important to make a good purchase. Because this is easier said than done we have created a list of the best oven mitts so you won’t risk burning your fingertips and can carry a hot oven dish across the kitchen without having to run your hands under the cold tap after. Here’s the pick of the best.

Quick Summary of Oven Mitts

 Editor’s Choice 
BIG RED HOUSE Oven Mitts
Check price on Amazonmore
 Best For Extreme Temperatures 
‘Ove’ Glove, Heat Resistant
Check price on Amazonmore
 Best Silicone  
Homwe Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
Check price on Amazonmore
 Best Oven Mitt Set 
Homwe Silicone Oven Mitts and Potholders (4-Piece Sets)
Check price on Amazonmore
 Best Long Cuffs 
San Jamar KT0215 Cool Touch Oven Mitt
Check price on Amazonmore
 Best Grip 
Cuisinart Silicone Oven Mitts
Check price on Amazonmore

BIG RED HOUSE Oven Mitts

 Editor’s Choice 

When buying oven gloves, you need a bit of flexibility to make sure your grip is constant as not being able to grasp a hot dish can spell disaster. On top of that, they need to be heat resistant to seriously high temperatures and these reliable oven mitts tick both boxes. With two gloves for maximum control, they are heat resistant up to 480 degrees so a steaming pot or scolding hot tray will not cause you discomfort.

The silicon stripe is what makes them so desirable as this gives you loads of grip over a smooth surface but the thick cotton design is flexible enough for you to feel and grasp. Made from BPA-free materials with a terrycloth interior they look the part and come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

It might be a little difficult to pick up a label that has been sticking out of a hot pan but for the bigger jobs, they are hard to beat, especially for the price.

PROS:

  • Heat resistant up to 480 degrees
  • Grippy silicone stripes
  • Comfortable cotton is flexible
  • Look great
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
CONS:

‘Ove’ Glove, Heat Resistant

 Best For Extreme Temperatures 

Out of all the products we reviewed, these are the most comfortable oven mitts. They are made from the same material that is used by firefighters called Kevlar and can withstand heats up to 540 degrees which is more than most. Because they fit more like a glove than a mitten they are incredibly flexible with every finger able to move with ease.

This means you can hold onto trays and pots without an issue. They are reliable because of the silicon grip strips that ensure you don’t drop whatever is in your hands. Because they are resistant to flames they are also a great option for anyone who is working around the BBQ.

PROS:

  • Heat resistant up to 540 degrees
  • Made from kevlar – same material used by firefighters
  • Every finger is flexible
  • Silicone non-slip grips
CONS:

  • Not as convenient to get on and off

Homwe Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt

 Best Silicone  

The added length of these 14.7 inches, sturdy oven mitts ensures your forearms are not at risk of being burnt as they are fine with temperatures of up 450 degrees. On top of this, they are flame-retardant and feature a quilted cotton lining that makes them comfortable when the heat is increasing.

The benefit of silicone oven mitts is that they are resistant to spills so if boiling water gets on them your hands will not be scolded. The texture pattern makes them grippy and what a lot of people like is that they are easy to clean but can go in the machine to wash them thoroughly. Made from BPA-free materials they have a decent amount of flexibility and come in a variety of sizes.

PROS:

  • Long 14.7 inch design
  • Flame retardant and resistant to spills
  • Textured pattern makes them grippy
CONS:

  • Can be on the large side for some people

Homwe Silicone Oven Mitts and Potholders (4-Piece Sets)

 Best Oven Mitt Set 

Everyone likes to get a little extra from a purchase which is what Homwe offers customers in their 4-piece set. It includes a pair of oven mitts and two potholders and is available in black, grey, blue, or red. The potholders measure 7 x 7 inches and are made from silicone to ensure the pots and pans don’t mark your sides.

The texture on the grip ensures these quality oven mitts don’t slip at the vital moment. Made from BPA-free materials one of the major benefits is the resistance to steam so even a freshly opened oven won’t scold your hands and certainly not your forearms as you get a lot of protection.

PROS:

  • Comes with 2 silicone potholders
  • Made from BPA-free materials
  • Good amount of grip
CONS:

  • Not as flexible as other brands

San Jamar KT0215 Cool Touch Oven Mitt

 Best Long Cuffs 

With the best oven mitts, you expect a good amount of protection and not many brands go as far to offer you the 15-inches that San Jamar does. Yes, these come in a few different sizes but a lot of people like the added forearm protection. Not to mention, they are heat resistant to up to a massive 900 degrees and can hold items of around 500 degrees for 30-second intervals.

They feature Nomex as well as kevlar stitching, two of the better materials for keeping you safe near heat and are easy to maintain because they are machine washable. The main issue is that you only get one and because of the durable and quality materials, it is more expensive than a lot of the competition.

PROS:

  • Forearm protection
  • Up to 900 degrees heat resistance
  • Quality materials Nomex and kevlar for protection
CONS:

  • Only get one oven mitt

Cuisinart Silicone Oven Mitts

 Best Grip 

A lot of oven gloves seem to be popular in red, whatever the reason, at least these are available in a variety of colors to please every taste. The grips are made from a BPA-free silicone with grooves to add a good amount of hold to the flexibility.

The position of the thumb is a little awkward but the premium insulation and soft cotton make them comfortable when on, it just might be a bit awkward to grip handles but you do get 2 in a pack and they are heat resistant for up to 500 degrees. There is a handing ring so you can keep them out of the way but remember to hand wash them which can be a little inconvenient.

PROS:

  • Made from BPA-free materials
  • Heat resistant up to 500 degrees
  • Well insulated and grippy
CONS:

  • Can’t go in the washing machine – have to hand wash them

Oven Mitts Guide

There never used to be as much choice so when you wanted an oven mitt you probably had one or two options and the only variation from the insulated cotton was probably color. Times have changed and there are plenty of options when it comes to oven mitts but this can work for and against customers.

Now, it is hard to tell what a quality product should be capable of which is why we have created the following buyer’s guide so you can hold steaming pots and pans without having to worry.

What To Look For In An Oven Mitt

Flexibility

When you are gripping the handles of a hot pot or just grabbing a tray of roast potatoes out the oven, you need to know that you can wrap your fingers over the sides and hold on until you have put it down on a heat resistant surface. When you feel your grasp failing, it can lead to accidents and these are avoidable.

The best oven mitts are those where you can move your fingers and feel your way around the hot surface.

Heat Resistance

A hot oven can reach near the 500-degree mark although the average oven will be closer to 400 degrees. Whatever yours is capable of, your oven mitt of choice needs to be able to withstand some seriously high digits.

Most companies will proudly tell you about their great heat resistance so when they do, make sure their product can withstand temperatures of around 450 degrees and above.

Grip

The smooth surfaces of pans and oven trays can be slippery, especially when there are hot water and steam rising. This is where a good amount of grip is essential. Look for indents and grooves in a silicone oven mitt or a cotton product that has grippy silicone lines to ensure nothing slips.

Comfort

You’re not going to wear your oven mitts in a snowball fight but they need to be comfortable enough to wear time and again. The better products will come with cotton lining to make them soft on your hands and not feel awkward to put on.

Easy To Clean

An oven mitt can go through a fair amount of abuse over a serious of weeks and months. You might be gripping the side of a pan and spill a little grease on there, or a bubbling pot might spit a little sauce. Eventually, you’re going to want to clean the oven mitts and for some products, this is a lot easier.

Silicone oven mitts tend to be easy to wipe with a damp cloth and some are fine to go in the washing machine. Cotton tends to stain easily and it can be hard to get stubborn marks out. As long as it is washing machine friendly, you shouldn’t have a problem maintaining them for a long time.

Good Length

It’s easy to forget about the sudden outpour of steam when opening a hot oven that causes you to back off. This is where a good length in your oven mitt is important. It gives you added protection and although some products are a bit excessive in their length (you can find plenty that are over 15 inches long) there is nothing wrong with giving yourself more protection.

Design

Although this shouldn’t be high on your list compared to the functionality it helps to find something you like the look of in your kitchen. It doesn’t have to match your kettle but most products come in a variety of colors to please most tastes.

Extras

So this isn’t a new piece of technology we’re talking about, no ones expecting to be able to talk to Alexa through their oven mitt but sometimes, extras can sweeten the deal. Even a hanging hook or lopp can be the difference between two similar products but you can find some that come with pot holders.

Different Materials of Oven Mitts

Cotton

Traditional oven mitts look something closer to the cotton or fabric types and these are softer and make it easy to maintain a good grasp on pots and pans. They get dirty but are easier to clean because they can go in the wash but are more susceptible to wear and tear.

Silicone

A silicone oven mitt often lacks a bit of flexibility but makes up for it in the grip. They wipe clean and are good at resisting heat from steam but most notably, silicone oven mitts are more durable and tend to last a very long time.

Cotton and Silicone

A lot of the oven mitts on the market will be a mix of both cotton and silicone. This gives you the best of both worlds making them comfortable, easy to grip and will be just as durable as a lot of the pure silicone products.

Kevlar

If it’s good enough for fireguards then its good enough for an oven mitt, kevlar gives you great steam protection and a heat resistance of around 500 degrees. They are as flexible as cotton oven mitts and machine washable so easy to clean.

Different Types of Oven Mitts

There isn’t a lot between the common types of oven mitts but the main differences involve your grip. The most common are those that are shaped like large mittens, hence the name. These have a natural feel to them but aren’t as flexible. Then you get those that are shaped with the thumb-shaped in the way your hand holds a puppet. These are fine when you are holding something but can be a little awkward.

For a lot of people, the glove shaped oven mitts are the best. They might be a little awkward to get on in a hurry but are flexible and allow you to move all your fingers for added grip.